Friday, February 8, 2013



Editor's Note

This post was written in part as a response to a post by Mike Schmidt over at Anglers Choice Flies titled, "Some Thoughts From The Middle" which was written in part as a response to a post by the guys at Fish Camp Rehab titled, "Standing In The Generation Gap" which was written in part as a response to a post by Matt Tucker over at The Ozark Chronicles titled, "The Conclave Is Dead...The Fishing Is Not." I strongly encourage you to find some time to pay a visit to each of the aforementioned sites and to continue visiting henceforward... lots of good old fashioned story telling and some nice pictures for the "visual learner" in the bunch.

In case you're sitting at your desk on your lunch break and don't have two hours to read the full scope of posts, I'll bring you up to speed on the discussion with a few snippets that struck a chord with me.

From Fish Camp Rehab:

"...Too few old geezer fly fishermen have anything interesting to say.Those who do avoid these organizations and events like the plague except to make a cameo appearance and then go fishing and hit the local watering hole with the young fellas, where they are treated like war heroes.  They’re no fools!"

"When your brand of fly fishing is no longer fun and exciting, that is when your brand of fly fishing begins to die."

"...if we persist on this path too long, we become ridiculous old geezers sitting alone in a church basement next to the White River on a splendid Ozarks Fall day choking down rancid pork and dry chicken talking about fly fishing when we should be out there fly fishing."

From The Ozark Chronicles:

"About the only thing I can tell you about the FFF is that they offer fly casting certifications…………and at the end of the day fly casting isn’t fly fishing."

"Secondly, it comes down to how I value my time.  I am married 35yo guy with two daughters (ages 15 and 10).  I am a partner in a small construction company in a midwest metro area and between work and family, I have very little time for anything else.   For me, after choosing to spend time away from my family and my business, going to a “banquet” is the last thing I want to do.  I have a hall pass and want to blow off some steam and fish"

From ACF:

"Both generations need to understand that the other has something valuable to offer.  We need to leverage those skills towards a common goal of ensuring our sport is around for the next generation to enjoy."

"The guys from the old school have the contacts and capital to get stuff done while the new school has the means to quickly get the word out en masse and mobilize large numbers of people."

SO, without further adieu, here are my thoughts on the subject - take 'em or leave 'em. 

Take a deep breath, Gen X'er; this might take more than 30 seconds.

"I haven't caught a fish in 3 weeks, and I've spent plenty of time trying. Don't misconstrue it - I'm none too pleased with the situation, but I'm also not losing sleep (beer helps, a lot). Whilst mired in this fishless funk I've had ample time to surf the interwebs to see the fish that other people ARE catching and to read/hear what they're saying about it. I've got mixed feelings.

During this same spell I ran into a non-angling buddy at the bar. He mentioned that he visited this blog from time to time and, as a professional web commerce consultant, offered his advice on how I could improve it.

"You should post more. You'd get more hits, more traffic and more advertising $$$. You should open a Twitter account, too."

Hmm. Food for thought. I'm buried up to my eyeballs in loans of all forms and fashions, and a little extra scratch on the side could go a long way. And whose to say it won't yet? I haven't written this avenue off by any means. But, I have my reservations.

For starters, I don't like to mince words and I write when I'm compelled to do so. Until somebody starts paying me to put pen to paper every day (Anybody? Anybody?), I've got bills to pay and fish to catch and I don't have time to sit here and write about or photograph every last one of them. And I'm not down with Twitter, at least not yet (never say never). I'm turned off by the immediacy of the whole thing, by the overwhelming infatuation with knowing what everyone else is doing, everyday, all the time. Clearly the application has its merits and in that regard I suppose, like a gun, it's all about how you use it.

But let's not go there.

Most of all, as it pertains to the fly fishing industry, I am turned off by the gratuitous pimping that I see from fellow anglers, most of them from my age group (under 30). "We" want so badly to set ourselves apart that we share every waking moment of our lives, every fish we catch, every fly we tie, in hopes that others will shower us with praise. Be that as it may. It is a simple fact of life that fisherfolk love fishporn. Big fish hero shots will never die, nor should they (look no further than this blog). All I ask is that we mix in a little humility. Some experiences are meant to be internalized. Humility is a sign of intelligence, demonstrating an awareness of a world beyond the self, an understanding that your good fortune is due only in small part to your own doings. Call it Buddhist bullshit, call it Zenmaster nonsense, call it whatever you want. But please, get out of your cyber bubble and stop being a douche.

Did I lose you?

Sorry. Here ya' go:

Now please, keep reading.

During the most recent lapse in Dudewater posts, two friends and I loaded up a jeep, drove 5+ hours in the dark through one of the worst winter storms I've ever seen, with a drift boat in tow, "slept" for 5 hours in the parking lot of a Michigan truck stop, nearly died of methane asphyxiation, woke up and drove 3 more hours - just to go fishing. We spent the next 48 hours in a drift boat full of water, fishing in the pouring rain and freezing our stones off. We were chasing steelhead. We landed 0 steelhead.

On the afternoon of the second day another boat pulled up aside us mid river. The vessel was occupied by two local guides - no names, please. Both were older than us -"tweeners," if you've been following the conversation - who could easily have blown past us and snubbed their noses at a couple outsiders. Instead, they anchored next to us and made small talk. In short time we were passing around moonshine and tossing each other beers while lunch cooked on the grill. They told us stories of places we'd never been but hoped to visit someday, and we told them how much we appreciated them sharing their river with us. It was a happenstance of The Brotherhood at it's finest, and catching or not catching fish was a sidebar.

This is the beauty of our sport; It is transcendent across demographics, across socio-economic status, even across language barriers. It began before us, and if we're careful, it will continue long after we're gone. But only if we're careful. We are a strong contingent. We are small, but we are mighty. If we dissolve, we are nothing.

So how do we bridge the gap? First off, we look the influencers of the old guard (the "war heroes" that Fish Camp Rehab refers to) in the eye, shake their hands firmly and say "Thank you." Better yet.... we ask questions. Then, we listen to the asnwers. We don't tell them the way we like to do it. We can learn a hell of a lot more by understanding the way it used to be than by telling Bob Clouser or Lefty that we like to tie their patterns with craft fur because it moves better. That may be true, but instead how about asking ole' Bobby about the days when you didn't need craft fur or anything other than a few pieces of bucktail on a hook to put 100 fish in the boat on the Susquehanna -  and how we get back to that?

Listen up boys and girls: Before you click "post" again,  Spend some time in thought. Tomorrow is NOT promised and only our legacy survives us. I am not saying don't share your experiences, but consider your effect on the resource and your peers. It all boils down to respect - if you're not dishing it, don't expect it in return.

And let's be perfectly clear here: This is NOT "New School VS. Old School," "Left VS. Right," or anything of the sort. There are far too many frivolous whose-side-are-you-on ultimatums being placed on us by the national media as it is. But a flat brim and surfer shades don't pre-qualify you for the brotherhood. They won't exclude you either, but you'd better bring a sixer and some good stories to the table if you plan to stick around. And please, don't take yourself so seriously.

The brotherhood (sisters welcome) of fly fishing is strong, but it lacks a unified voice. And that voice should be saying this: We want more public fishing access and better protection for species and habitat, lest we should all end up fishless. It's time for my generation to get our shit together and let the old guard know that with all due respect - and I mean that - we'll take it from here.


  1. That's the whole point, but it takes both sides working for the common good. The young guns need to put down the Xbox controllers when they aren't fishing long enough to do some of the boring admin heavy lifting that is absolutely required to hold things together and move things forward as a community. The old guard needs to realize that free time and money aren't the only pre-requisites for leadership. You also need a vision and methodology that are RELEVANT to society now and in the future. Nostalgia is great. Historical awareness is AWESOME! But ignorance and incompetency of current social norms, trends, phenomena, and the technology and politics that drive them is inexcusable in leaders. If you are deficient in these areas, you either have to GET efficient fast or get out of the way.

    Our personal ego needs are not what should be driving our efforts to preserve and promote fly fishing and conservation efforts. And when we get the horse in front of the cart, we will find that the ego needs take care of themselves - because we made good choices that are bearing more and better fruit than we realized was possible.

  2. "...If we dissolve, we are nothing."
    couldn't say it any better. I am caught in the middle, a new sprung organism who believes there is hope for my daughters generation that they may have good fishing again, someday. So I work closely with old school, pay close attention to thier personal connections and make the introductions with other natural resources so when the time comes, we are more than a handshake, we are a nod and a nickname basis. Thank you for a younger tha fresh look at it all. The next time you don't want to choke yourself out- drop me a line. Tight Lines,

  3. This is one of...if not THE...most important conversations in fishing since C&R. And I'm glad that so many bloggers are taking the time to toss their 2 cents into the fly fishing blogosphere on the subject.

    I just returned from the Guadalupe River TU Troutfest and MidSouth Regional Meeting in New Braunfels a week or so ago. I was up there as a vendor for Cheeky Fly Fishing. Let me tell y'all -- that was the way an event like that should be done! Riverside, outdoors under a big top, in a campground/raft outfitter's place with some cabins and big pro shop (Rio Raft), within easy striking distance of a couple of towns with lodging on a major Interstate highway and less than an hour from 2 International airports. Tons of stuff for ALL AGES to do, see, learn, eat, drink, smell, touch, play with, buy, etc. Headliners: Lefty Kreh (old school), Taylor Streit (Yuppie/hippie anglers), and Wanda Taylor (soccer mom anglers). Tyler Befus was there, too. (kids) There were games for adults and kids. There was an airsoft shooting gallery put on by courtesy of the Texas State Rifle Assn -- a fly fishing event! Can you believe that stuff? There were saltwater and freshwater, warm and cold water vendors, exhibitors, and presenters. There were kayak, canoe, and wade fishing demos. There was Tenkara, spey, and single-handed casting lessons. The full spectrum of fishing related arts and crafts was well represented. The F3T was presented outdoors against the river bluff as a backdrop with lawn seating. There was live music. There were GREAT food vendors. There was NO $4 BOTTLED WATER!!!! It was $1. A "grande" coffee was $1.50. Take that Starbuck. The swag was fresh, contemporary, fun, and not left over from the past 3 years. It sold like hotcakes at a prayer breakfast, but for a lot more $$$.

    But I'm not writing to tell y'all about the event. I took a minute to tell y'all that this topic was one of the two or three major subjects of discussion the entire 3 days of the festival among the folks in the leadership set. They were almost ALL talking about it. They've been reading these blogs and they are hearing the message. They're thinking and asking questions. And THAT, my fellow bloggers, is the whole point behind what we do. Congratulations, and keep up the good work! It does matter.

    1. Ken,

      Thanks for taking the time to post. I appreciate your readership and, most importantly, your feedback! I literally check posts everyday to see if any comments have popped up. As much energy as I put into my writing, it means nothing if it's not hitting home with somebody. And this topic especially strikes a chord with so many people. All I can say is that I promise I'm doing my best to put my money where my mouth is on this one and working daily to use what reach I have to create more angling opportunities and to offer education and inspiration to would-be anglers. It's been a mission of mine from the start and I remain committed. Keep your posts and feedback - positive or negative - coming!



  4. good stuff, i dig the blog.

  5. Bloggers are attention whores, get over yourselves.

  6. There are as many different approaches to the sport of fly fishing as there are participants, but there are several easy-to-characterize subgroups. There are the "old geezers", retired guys with all the time and money. They may be highly experienced fishermen with deep understanding of the sport. Then, of course, they may just think they know something, but all they really know is how to open their wallets. They brag about the fish they catch when all they really did was follow instructions. I should point out that I am hoping to someday become an "old geezer" with enough resources to indulge in a massive pursuit of trout.

    Then there are the pros, the guides who spend hundreds of days a year on the water and know how to catch fish in almost any conditions. We amateurs would like to be as good as the pro, but it will never happen.

    The final group is made up of the working stiffs, like me. We work when we have to and fish when we can. Each one of us can occassionally hook a fish. When we do we think, 'yes, I am the man'. The power we have over the fish inspires us. We are tempted to believe we have unique insight that the average man does not possess.

    But, it's all BS. Every one of us, except the pro, is just out goofing off. I really don't understand the apparent animosity between the different age groups. I've never experienced it myself. Then again, I don't attend any fly fishing meetings, banquets or conclaves. If I need to go into a fly shop, I get in, buy what I need and get out. I send a modest annual check to Trout Unlimited. I pick up my streamside trash (and occassionally someone else's). I wade out into the cool, clear water and toss my fly into a likely looking pocket. Maybe my indicator dips and I stick a nice one. Maybe he drills out into the fast water, turns and races downstream. At that moment, age, technology level or taste in music have little affect on how I feel. At that moment, I think we all feel the same.